Brazilian Hypocrisy: Green Talk and Brown Actions

Brazil’s massive 13 December 2023 auction of oil and gas drilling rights betrays a glaring hypocrisy in view of the country’s discourse on climate change. The fossil fuels to be extracted would be a climate-change “bomb”. They also signal no intent to end extraction soon.

The auctioned areas impact Indigenous and other traditional peoples, Amazonian protected areas for biodiversity, coral reefs and marine biodiversity hotspots. Areas still “under study” for future auctions include the vital Trans-Purus rainforest area in Brazil’s state of Amazonas.

Brazil’s President Lula needs to control his anti-environmental ministers and replace some of them, such as the minister of mines and energy.

One day after the end of the COP28 climate summit, Brazil’s National Petroleum Agency (ANP) conducted what is known as the “End-of-the-World” auction, selling off drilling rights in 602 new exploration areas, including 21 in the Amazon River basin.

More than half (12 blocks) are located in areas that directly impact up to 20 Indigenous lands and the buffer zones of at least 15 conservation units (protected areas for biodiversity.

Also included are blocks affecting demarcated quilombola territories, which are areas inhabited by the descendants of Africans who escaped from slavery in past centuries; quilombolas have the same rights as Indigenous peoples under Brazil’s constitution.

The offering also included environmentally sensitive areas for offshore drilling and coral reef areas all along the coast of Brazil. Two offshore areas offered received no bids, apparently because their fame would make them a reputational risk: the area around the Fernando de Neronha islands and the Atol das Rocas.

Areas “under study,” not included in the present auction, include the first part of the disastrous “Solimões Sedimentary Area” oil and gas project. This project would drive road building and deforestation in the vast Tran-Purus area in the western half of the state of Amazonas.

The timing of the auction certainly shows the complete disconnect between the Lula administration’s discourse on the environment and the most consequential concrete actions the government is taking. It is certainly coincidental that the auction is one day after COP28, perhaps suggesting that it was postponed slightly so as not to add one more scandalous event during the COP itself.

However, the President was OK with Brazil joining the OPEC+ group of oil-exporting countries during the event, drawing attention to the same type of hypocrisy and earning Brazil a “fossil-of-the-day” prize at COP28.

The carbon emissions from the oil to be pumped and burned represent a “bomb” for climate change. The auction also signals that the Brazilian government and the companies investing in the drilling blocks, including Brazil’s government oil company (Petrobras), are not planning to end fossil fuel extraction within the next few years during which this needs to occur to prevent crossing a tipping point leading to uncontrollable global warming.

The impacts of oil extraction in indigenous areas and areas with other traditional peoples is often catastrophic, as shown by the experience in Peru and Ecuador. In addition to the social and health impacts of contact with the workers in the oil projects, leaks and spills are common, affecting the fish and other resources that support the traditional people.

The auction is shameful in all respects, including the obvious inconsistency with Brazil’s statements at COP28. Internally, it shows once again that only the Ministry of the Environment is committed to containing environmental damage, while the rest of the government feels free to implement the most damaging projects, as by building Highway BR-319 and other roads opening Amazon forest to deforestation, legalizing illegal land claims in government land (one of the main drivers of deforestation), authorizing over 500 dangerous agricultural chemicals, and initiating and expanding oil extraction projects including both those in areas that damage tropical forest and indigenous peoples and offshore oil extraction in the most biologically diverse and fragile areas and at depths at which leaks cannot be contained.

President Lula needs to control the anti-environmental tendencies of his ministers, and some, such as the minister of mines and energy, need to be replaced immediately.

This article appeared originally in Mongabay. An earlier version of this text was published in Portuguese by Amazônia Real.


You May Also Like

Brazil's national bird, the toucan, in the Amazon forest

For Amazon’s Largest Restoration Ever the Forest Will Get 73 Million New Trees in Six Years

A major initiative for the restoration of degraded areas in the Brazilian Amazon calls ...

Getting a Piece of Brazil

Business Getting a Piece of Brazil There is an expression “Who doesn’t register is ...

Brazil Is Losing Conservation Reserves. Mining Interests Seem to Be Behind the Move

New legislation in Brazil has been proposed to reduce or eliminate several Amazon conservation ...

Motoboys protest in Brazil's capital city, Brasília. Photo: Marcelo Camargo/Ag Brasil

Badly Hit by Covid-19, Brazil and Latin America May Become Trapped in a Gig Economy

Coronavirus has hit the healthcare systems and societies of the global south even harder ...

Stimulus Package: Brazil Gets US$ 4.2 Bi to Buy from Ambulances to Missile Launchers

Faced with a sluggish economy, the Brazilian government announced the expansion of the Accelerated ...

A worker seen in a coffee farm during operation to identify slave workers in Minas Gerais state. REUTERS/Adriano Machado

Slave Workers Rescued in Brazil Were as Young as Nine

A large Brazilian tobacco exporter has been charged with using slave labor in the ...

At UN, Brazil President Praises Democracy and Asks Foreigners to Invest in His Country

In the speech marking the opening of the 71st United Nations (UN) General Assembly, ...

An invasive lionfish at Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary in the Gulf of Mexico. G. P. Schmahl/NOAA, CC BY

Arrival of Voracious Lionfish to Brazilian Waters Is a Threat of an Ecological Disaster

Brazil’s coastal waters teem with a rich array of species that paint a living ...

The Worst Ever: Brazil’s GDP Drops 7.2% in the 2015-2016 Period

Brazil’s economic woes continue as the country’s worst-ever recession unexpectedly deepened at the end ...